#FakeNews in the Time of Corona

Disclaimer: I don’t have any professional training in fact-checking. Fortunately, you don’t need any to combat fake news.

Now that Mother Nature has put us in us our place, let us all vow to hold on to our sanity during this pandemic. It’s bad enough spreading and/or developing a disease with no vaccine and no treatment, let alone developing and/or spreading fake news about said disease.

How do you know whether or not that Whatsapp forward mentioning that COVID-19 infection can be cured by drinking tea (ineffective but go ahead), bathing in hydrogen peroxide (don’t) or gargling with bleach (definitely DON’T!) is fake? Why even bother to verify bad news, easy cure claims or conspiracy theories, when the situation is already dire and forwarding staff feels like doing something, especially during isolation? Does it matter if a Facebook post falsely claims that a novel published in 1981 (prophetic, eh?) contains proof that the Chinese Government created COVID-19 in a laboratory?

Let us first get the “why” out of the way. Fake news is harmful, period. It can cause panic and be counterproductive. It can convince gullible people to try things that are harmful. It can catalyze social conflict and fuel xenophobia and racism. It can aide charlatans to profit off of people’s fear and ignorance. These are of course just examples of ill effects of fake news, and are by no means exhaustive.

Once you are mentally prepared to find and fight disinformation, it is not that difficult to spot. Following are some methods that I personally use to separate fact from fiction on social media platforms.

Platform: If you read something on a platform where anyone can publish anything without vetting, be very skeptical about the information. To borrow a phrase from Mother Jones journalist Sinduja Rangarajan, platforms like Whatsapp, Facebook, Twitter and Instagram are global petri dishes of misinformation. The personal credentials of the people who shared the post on your feed do not matter. You may believe that your boss or cousin or neighbour with impeccable moral character would never share a false story. However, they might have seen the post from someone who they know and trust in real life and have become a link in the chain of misinformation.

To summarize, be skeptical of information published on non-vetted platforms and do not equate someone’s trustworthiness in real life to the truthfulness of their posts on social media.

Tall Claims and Bad Writing: If a news story seems too good, too bad or too outrageous to be true, it probably is. Keep an eye out for lots of superlatives and exclamatory signs. Misspelled words, incorrect grammar and overly emotional language are other telltale signs of fake news. Also, if a cure for coronavirus is discovered, surely you won’t come to know about it first from a badly written random forwarded post on a random Whatsapp group.

Keyword Search: Articles contain certain significant representative words. If you search these words using a search engine (google.com, duckduckgo.com etc.), there is a high chance that you will find fact-checking articles about the dubious article. For example, a post about antioxidants in tea preventing and curing coronavirus has recently gone viral on Facebook and Whatsapp. If you search “tea cure coronavirus”, you’ll find multiple articles that have thoroughly debunked the entire post. If you are not sure what keywords to search, you can also copy the first one or two sentences from the dubious post and paste it in the search engine. How do you know if a fact-checking article is reliable? Check the publishing platform. If it is the site of a registered and reputed media organization, there is a high chance that it can be trusted. Additionally, you can yourself search and vet the individual claims made in the fact-checking articles. For example, the tea-cures-coronavirus post claims that it is sourced from a breaking news report from CNN. The fact-checking articles claim that there has been no such reporting by CNN. You can go to see CNN site and see for yourself that the fact-checkers are correct.

To summarize, search keywords or sentences from the dubious article. You’ll most likely come to know whether or not it is factual.

Reverse Image Search: Misleading, edited, out-of-context photos also circulate a lot on social media platforms. The origin of these photos can be easily verifies using reverse image search. For example, an image of a man and a woman in medical scrubs standing face to face recently made the rounds on social media. The caption (written in an overtly emotional language) claimed that they were a physician couple in Italy who treated many COVID-19 patients, got infected themselves and shared a last kiss before dying. However, reverse image search showed that the original picture was taken at the Barcelona airport in Spain. An additional red flag in the image caption was that it did not mention the doctors’ names.

Authentic Source, Inauthentic News: Unfortunately, sometimes even authentic news platforms publish misleading or outright false stories. Though there is a good chance of these stories being vetted post publication and subsequently being edited or taken down, the credibility provided by the source may increase the reach and impact of these stories.

In such cases, first vet the author. Make sure that the author is qualified to give opinion on the topic(s) of the article and has no conflict of interest. For example, suppose Dr. X has claimed in an article on a legit news site that COVID-19 outbreak is under control and domestic flight services should be immediately restored to normal. It may be tempting to believe the claim without verifying. However, if Dr. X turns out to be not a medical doctor but a doctorate in a completely non-medical field (not qualified) and the CEO of an airline (conflict of interest), take the claims in the article with a massive grain of salt. Further, vet the story by looking at other credible news platforms. If it is true, it will be likely reported by multiple news outlets. If it is false, there is a good chance that it will be fact-checked and debunked by multiple other credible news organizations.

Finally, when in doubt, refer to WHO guidelines on COVID-19 and follow the instructions from the Government. Remember, we are all in this together.

During this time of unprecedented crisis, it will be great not to add extra garbage to the massive vat of existing fake news. Also to think critically and debunk false claims can serve as a fun mental exercise-cum-pastime during isolation. Stay safe. Stay physically and mentally stimulated. As my favourite author Douglas Adams said, Don’t Panic!

Day 26

Sleeping early, waking up early and following a fixed routine is going on well. Last night I had a very, very weird and very, very technology-infused dream. I thought of writing it down in the morning but the details kept slipping away and I finally gave up on it. It could have probably made into a very fine B-grade sci-fi movie. Anyway, this gave me the motivation to start a dream journal.

Day 25

25 down, 3 more to go. Well, hopefully it will not end at 3. For the I have been practicing intermittent fasting in which I eat only within an 8-hour window. So far it has proved to be good. It is a wonderful feeling to actually feel hungry before dinner and actually feel sleepy before going to bed. Good habits are good, you just have to motivate yourself to develop those.

Day 24

The nights are unusually cold this year. Last year I could not have imagined sleeping under a sheet during April. This is helping me a lot in having a comfortable sleep.

Last night there was a thunderstorm that lasted for about an hour. I absolutely love the rain. I love getting soaked in the rain. I love watching the rain through the window. I love the damp smell rising from the earth during and after rainfall. I love watching the leaves on the trees getting a thorough shower. I also love the feeling of gradually falling asleep while it’s raining outside. My mind feels peaceful and my heart feels content. My body feels comfortable and relaxed. Happy memories from long past come to visit me. They gently coo me to sleep. That’s how I slept last night.

A bright sun welcomed me in the morning, a little too bright for comfort. As I went through my morning routine, a sense of serenity filled my soul. It felt like rain was still pouring on me in the form of bliss.

Day 23

It was a lazy Sunday. I slept for about 10 hours. I need to be more careful not to slip up like this again. One good thing about maintaining an early-to-bed-early-to-rise schedule is that it makes doing the everyday chores easier. Things tend to run like clockwork. I am glad that I am not being bogged down by piles of unwashed clothes, for example. Following a set routine has it’s benefits. It also means that I get to enjoy an occasional lazy Sunday watching movies and Comedy Central sketches.

Day 21

Last night was one of those rare ones when I had interrupted sleep. I had a vivid bad dream which woke me up around 2-30 am. When your brain is exhausted, it starts to distort reality. My brain happily made me believe that my distress was real, that whatever bad things I was dreaming about were real. (Another reason not to become sleep deprived.) Finally I was able to get a grip on reality and return to the present. I had to listen to some soothing audios to calm myself and go back to sleep. I woke up much later than expected in the morning.

I am not really sure why I had such a vivid bad dream that was distressing enough to wake me up. Once I fall asleep, I almost never wake up during the night. My routine has remained same as previous days. If this happens again I’ll try to identify patterns but as of now I am considering it an outlier.

Day 20

3 weeks of the challenge is almost over and things seems to have fallen into place. I’m sleeping at a fixed time ( a little later than my liking), waking up at a scheduled time and having a good night’s rest everyday.

Now that I’m consciously trying to live in the moment and spend time with my own thoughts, I am noticing patterns in my habits and routine that I’d like to change. I want to now work on them one by one and continue living a healthy and happy life.

Day 19

It’s going on great. I am finally becoming a morning person and being increasingly more productive days compared to the time before taking this challenge. Today I attended a talk on mental health awareness arranged by the counselling centre of my institute. I was diagnosed with major depressive disorder (moderate recurring) exactly two years ago and being treated at the counselling centre ever since. I remember the days of complete non-functionality and utter despair before getting diagnosed. I would mindlessly surf the Internet till 3 or 4 am, then collapse in bed without brushing my teeth, get up after 10 am with my body full of cramps and my mind full of anxiety, and then go to lab and do nothing while pretending to work. I had completely forgotten how did it feel like to be properly rested, relaxed and refreshed. I feel immensely happy to be able to gradually return to a healthy lifestyle. I also feel grateful for the people and resources that helped me fight depression. It feels good to have a healthy sleep cycle. It feels good to have a healthy lifestyle overall.

Oh, by the way – there was a quiz at the end of the talk. I won it and received a box of chocolates as reward. Life’s good, ha!

Day 18

While I slept and woke up per schedule, I had a bad, bad dream in the early morning. It was so bad that it took a long time and lots of effort to shake of the feeling of incredible sadness and anxiety. But after waking up one of my cats – the one who is most attached to me – jumped on me demanding pets and blew away all my bad feelings with his purr-machine running at full capacity. I’m one lucky cat-mom.

I sometimes whether or not to introduce my cats in my posts.